Sign up to our classic game. Get three teams for just £6
If fortune really did favour the brave, Renault would be the bestselling car
manufacturer on earth. The one-time maker of the world’s dullest cars —
remember that mind-numbingly boring former European car of the year, the
Renault 9? — has more guts in one of its kicked-out boot-lids than most
rivals can muster in their entire ranges.
This new-found love of design has been a hit-and-miss affair, though. The Vel
Satis executive hatchback is ugly, dynamically off the pace and if I never
drove another I wouldn’t miss it. Although the Avantime MPV-coupé hybrid at
least looks good it is conceptually too weird for most tastes. But where it
really matters, in the biggest car category in Europe, the new Mégane family
hatch has hit the spot. Great looking, good to drive and well executed, it
deserves its recent car of the year title as much as its forebear did not.
Which brings me to the new Espace. It’s nearly 20 years since this car
invented the MPV category but it has often made me feel like one of those
poor souls who don’t find Vic Reeves funny. While colleagues banged on about
how clever it was, I was just bewildered. Why have an Espace when a Ford
Galaxy was so much better to live with and drive? But we are all entitled to
our moments of enlightenment. It took the first episode of Shooting Stars
before I got Vic Reeves and this generation, the fourth, before I understood
the Espace.
Not that it’s a difficult car to criticise, particularly as it’s coming to
market just after the impressive new Citroën C8 and its Peugeot 807 and Fiat
Ulysse sisters. They have sliding doors, the Espace does not. They offer
eight seats, the Espace has seven. They are full of innovative and useful
features, like doors that open by remote control and a wide-angle interior
mirror; the Espace is not.
But if the Espace has fallen behind in terms of what it does, it has taken a
commanding lead in the way it does it. I have long waited for an MPV that
does not make you feel as if you have sold out entirely to the pocket
dictators on the back seat, a feat achieved at last by the Espace.
I like the originality of its exterior and love its cabin. Again it is not
without fault: the central electronic instruments are a confused splat of
light-emitting digits, but the minimalist fascia is restful and uncluttered
by the usual stereo and ventilation switches. Visibility is also superb,
thanks to skinny roof pillars.
The Espace also solves the people carrier’s perennial power problem. In the
past, MPVs have forced you to choose between unrefined but frugal diesels,
gutless small-capacity petrol engines or profligate large petrol power
plants. Now the Espace comes with a 3 litre 180bhp diesel V6, combining near
130mph potential and 30mpg in normal running. Smooth at idle and very quiet
at speed, it is what MPVs have been crying out for.
In fact, it is at speed that this Espace impresses most, wafting along with
the fast-lane cruisers, smooth riding even when fully laden and always with
plenty in reserve. Conversely, it’s at its worst when driven empty around
town, where it is too large and the ride is unyielding.
But the most interesting aspect of this Espace is its tacit acknowledgment
that the genre it founded has gone far enough down the road to practicality.
Instead, Renault has cleverly taken the Espace in a new direction, gambling
that what MPV buyers really want, even more than another dozen cup-holders,
is the chance to kid themselves that buying an MPV is a matter of choice
rather than circumstance. Clearly it’s an illusion, yet its class and
skilful execution get the Espace close to where it’s possible to suspend
disbelief.
But Renault will make you pay for such sophistication. The cheapest V6 diesel
Espace costs £28,985, the most expensive £33,735. It would be a shame if
that were to deter those who need six or more seats yet want to drive with
their hearts somewhere other than in their boots, for this is the car to
deliver that dream.
VITAL STATISTICS
Model Renault Espace 3.0 dCi
Engine type V6 turbodiesel, 2958cc
Power/Torque 180bhp @ 4400rpm / 258 lb ft @ 1800rpm
Transmission Five-speed automatic
Suspension (front) MacPherson struts, coil springs, anti-roll
bar; (rear) torsion beam axle, trailing arms, coil springs, anti-roll bar
Tyres 225/55 R17
Fuel/CO2 29.7mpg (combined) / 252g/km
Top speed 127mph
Acceleration 0 to 60mph: 10.4sec
Company car tax £4,032 for a higher-rate taxpayer
Price £28,985
Verdict The most sophisticated MPV yet but flawed and too
expensive